Which uses of Bonus-Action spellcasting are legal?

Question

Looking at other questions about casting spells as a bonus action has left me trying to keep a lot of information in my head about whether a given combination of spells is legal according to the official 5th edition spellcasting rules.

So I'd like to consolidate all these rules into a single easily accessible table, containing all the possible combinations of spells that could possibly be cast in a single turn, and hopefully create an easy reference for future use. But I'm not certain about how some of these combinations should be treated.

Based on the second question I linked, the ordering doesn't matter, so I've simplified the chart to ignore order of these actions, and only focus on what actions are being taken. But if I'm mistaken (i.e. the answer provided to that question was wrong) then this table will need adjusting.

Action	Bonus Action	Action Surge	LEGAL?
Non-Cantrip			Yes
Cantrip			Yes
	Non-Cantrip		Yes
	Cantrip		Yes
Non-Cantrip	Cantrip		No
Cantrip	Non-Cantrip		Yes
Non-Cantrip	Non-Cantrip		No
Cantrip	Cantrip		Yes
Non-Cantrip		Cantrip	Yes
Non-Cantrip		Non-Cantrip	?Yes?
Cantrip		Non-Cantrip	?Yes?
Cantrip		Cantrip	Yes
Cantrip	Non-Cantrip	Non-Cantrip	?No?
Non-Cantrip	Cantrip	Non-Cantrip	?No?
Non-Cantrip	Non-Cantrip	Non-Cantrip	?No?
Non-Cantrip	Non-Cantrip	Cantrip	?No?
Cantrip	Non-Cantrip	Cantrip	?Yes?
Non-Cantrip	Cantrip	Cantrip	?No?
Cantrip	Cantrip	Non-Cantrip	?No?
Cantrip	Cantrip	Cantrip	Yes

Is this table (Column 4 in particular) correct?

The core issue for me is that it's not clear to me how Action Surges interact with the spellcasting rules, hence the question marks listed there. It seems like an Action Surge might permit 2 leveled spells to be cast in a turn, unless a Bonus Action is used to cast a spell, in which case this is no longer permitted. If this is correct, then my table above should be correct, minus the question marks. But I need that validated.

Your table is missing a column for reaction spellcasting, which is impeded by bonus action spellcasting just like action surge spellcasting is. — Please stop being evil, Feb 26 '20 at 03:15
Specifically, reactions performed on the caster's turn. This prevents a caster from hitting themselves with Fireball and then using Absorb Elements to mitigate some of it or from casting Counterspell against an opponent's Counterspell (which was countering the caster's spell). — Axoren, Feb 26 '20 at 03:35
...or using a cantrip in place of an opportunity attack (via War Caster) to hit someone that you'd forced to run away via dissonant whispers. Not legal, as it is a cantrip, but not with a casting time of one action. Reaction spellcasting is actually impeded just a little bit more. — Ben Barden, Feb 02 '21 at 19:35

score 42 · Accepted Answer · edited Mar 02 '22 at 00:03

The table is entirely correct

Action Surge does not interact in any way with the bonus-action spell rule (other than being limited in the same way as other spells if you use a bonus action spell). The bonus-action rule is only used for spells with a bonus-action casting time:

A spell cast with a bonus action is especially swift. You must use a bonus action on your turn to cast the spell [...] You can’t cast another spell during the same turn [that you would cast a bonus-action spell], except for a cantrip with a casting time of 1 action.

This is also further explained in one of the answers in the official rules clarification document Sage Advice Compendium (which is also here on D&D Beyond):

Is there a limit on the number of spells you can cast on your turn?

[...]

If you cast a spell [...] with a bonus action, you can cast another spell with your action, but that other spell must be a cantrip. Keep in mind that this particular limit is specific to spells that use a bonus action. For instance, if you cast a second spell using Action Surge, you aren’t limited to casting a cantrip with it.

Basically, if you cast (or will cast) a bonus-action spell (cantrip or non-cantrip) in a turn, no other non-cantrip spells (even ones using the action from Action Surge) can be cast.

The last sentence captures the rule perfectly. No need for a big table or long discussions. It's a simple rule to follow. — GreySage, Oct 16 '18 at 16:55
@rpeinhardt Those situations are accurate. If you cast a bonus action cantrip, you cannot cast a non-cantrip with your action. No matter what type of bonus action spell is cast, all other spells in that turn must be cantrips. — David Coffron, Oct 16 '18 at 17:32
@3C273 I'd love to understand what you mean as you may be right, but that would be the realm of discussion. If you'd join me in this chat room I'll here you out and perhaps we can reach an agreement (or perhaps not, either way would help me understand the game better). — David Coffron, Oct 17 '18 at 05:47

score 11 · Answer 2 · edited Mar 02 '22 at 00:06

11

Your table is correct, but can be dramatically simplified to this one, which I threw together in sheets, sorry for relative simplicity: and a text-friendlier version:

Level of Spell Cast As Action(*)	Level of Spell Cast As Bonus Action	Legal?
Any	None	TRUE
None	Any	TRUE
Cantrip	Any	TRUE
Level 1+	Any	FALSE

(*) Including during Action Surge

As above, this is based upon the summary in David Coffron's answer:

Basically, if you cast (or will cast) a bonus-action spell (cantrip or non-cantrip) in a turn, no other non-cantrip spells (even ones using the action from Action Surge) can be cast.

edited Mar 02 '22 at 00:06

V2Blast

49,864
10
220
304

answered Dec 16 '19 at 08:56

Cireo

867
6
13

2

I find the column title "max action / surge spell level" confusing, the chart is nice but maybe change title, or include a legend that explains the column titles. – Amethyst Wizard Feb 26 '20 at 03:55
1

Perhaps worth mentioning somewhere that a Sorcerer casting a cantrip + leveled spell both with 1-action cast time must Quicken the leveled spell, not the cantrip, to make it work. We now have a whole Q&A about that, Can I cast the Cure Wounds spell as an action, then use the sorcerer's Metamagic option Quickened Spell to cast Eldritch Blast as a bonus action? which seems like overkill. – Peter Cordes Mar 03 '22 at 02:47
2

These table leave out reactions: RAW, casting anything as a bonus action is incompatible with casting anything else except a 1-action cantrip. That includes Shield from an OA, or Counterspell of someone else's Counterspell. So if you want to cast multiple non-cantrips on a turn, you need to not cast as a bonus action. Casting multiple spells in a single round – Peter Cordes Mar 03 '22 at 02:49

Adeptus · Answer 3 · 2022-09-08T00:45:03.690

4

The table of allowed spells can be simplified:

Bonus Action spells	Action spells	Action Surge spells	Reaction spells (on caster's turn)
Any	Cantrip	Cantrip	None
None	Any	Any	Any

Anything not on this table, is not allowed.

edited Sep 08 '22 at 00:45

answered Sep 07 '22 at 06:41

Adeptus

28,475
5
84
127

score -1 · Answer 4 · edited Apr 27 '23 at 15:03

The table is correct

The rule from page 202 PHB is:

A spell cast with a bonus action is especially swift. You must use a bonus action on your turn to cast the spell, provided that you haven’t already taken a bonus action this turn. You can’t cast another spell during the same turn, except for a cantrip with a casting time of 1 action.

By this text, you only can cast only a single additional cantrip on the turn where you cast a spell as a bonus action. The text says "you can't cast another spell during the same turn, except for a cantrip", it does not say "you can't cast other spells during the same turn, except for cantrips".

However, in Xanathar's Guide to Everything which was printed later, under Ten Rules to Remember (page 5), this same rule is described as follows:

BONUS ACTION SPELLS
If you want to cast a spell that has a casting time of 1 bonus action, remember that you can't cast any other spells before or after it on the same turn, except for cantrips with a casting time of 1 action.

This is exactly the wording needed to allow multiple cantrips. Because that section is not about optional, additional rules like most of Xanathar, and because it is printed later, it overrides the PHB text.

It is the use of a bonus action spell, no matter if used for a cantrip or levelled spell, that is imposing a restriction. The table thus can be arranged differently to show the rule more clearly, with the bonus action as predicate in the first column. (You can further simplify it, as it makes no diffrence if you cast a cantrip or a leveled spell with your bonus action):

Bonus Action	Action	Action Surge*	Legal
	Cantrip or Leveled		Yes
		Cantrip or Leveled	Yes
	Cantrip or Leveled	Cantrip or Leveled	Yes
Cantrip or Leveled	Cantrip		Yes
Cantrip or Leveled		Cantrip	Yes
Cantrip or Leveled	Cantrip	Cantrip	Yes
Cantrip or Leveled	Leveled		No
Cantrip or Leveled		Leveled	No
Cantrip or Leveled	Cantrip	Leveled	No
Cantrip or Leveled	Leveled	Cantrip	No
Cantrip or Leveled	Leveled	Leveled	No

(*) Action Surge could also be a Reaction. One could have both an action surge and a reaction in the same turn, which would blow the table up to triple the size (as you need another column with values of empty, Cantrip and Leveled), but it would not change the rule that as soon as there is a bonus action spell of any kind, only 1-action cantrips are legal.

Downvoters: can you provide some feedback on why you think this is not right? Thank you. — Nobody the Hobgoblin, Jun 02 '22 at 10:35
Personally, I just don’t think the rule means what you say it means, so I downvoted. There’s no feedback for improvement I can give, I just think it’s incorrect. — Thomas Markov, Jun 02 '22 at 12:26
@ThomasMarkov Thank you for the explanation, I appreciate it. — Nobody the Hobgoblin, Jun 02 '22 at 12:29
I don't agree with the conclusion presented by this answer, but I do like having it, because it further justifies for me my decision to completely strike the Bonus Action Spellcasting rule from use at any table I DM—that is to say: any time I am DMing, this rule doesn't exist and spells cast as a bonus action do not impose restrictions on any further spellcasting that occurs during the same turn. It further cements for me the opinion that WotC did a poor job vetting and testing this rule in play. — Xirema, Jun 03 '22 at 00:57
@Xirema, I today found another piece of rules text in Xanathar which supports your view and is worded allowing multiple cantrips. Since this is printed later than the PHB text, I think it technically is overriding it, so your reading is correct after all. I update the answer to reflect this. — Nobody the Hobgoblin, Jun 26 '22 at 11:17
To explain my downvote on a correct answer, it is because the answer is now unnecessary. You started off with an entirely different take, and received votes on that take, and have now reversed the answer to match all of the existing. Changing your mind is totally fine, but a drastic change just to match all of the other answers makes this answer unnecessary for me and a poor reflection of the votes that it has. — NotArch, Apr 27 '23 at 14:31
@nautarch Thanks for the explanation. I changed it when I later discovered the XgtE supporting text, which resulted in the change of conclusion. I agree its a bit awkward to now have one more answer to that effect. — Nobody the Hobgoblin, Apr 27 '23 at 15:02

Which uses of Bonus-Action spellcasting are legal?

Is this table (Column 4 in particular) correct?

4 Answers4

The table is entirely correct

The table is correct

Linked

Related