Questions tagged [endogeneity]

Endogeneity refers to a situation where an explanatory variable in a model is correlated with the error term. Endogeneity induces biased parameter estimates. This is an important problem when working with observational data and the goal is causal inference.

If two variables, $X_1~\&~X_2$, are correlated with each other and both are entered into a model, the result will be some amount of collinearity, if one is left out of the model, and it actually does have an effect on the response, the result will be endogeneity. The effect of the omitted variable will be attributed to the variable that is in the model by virtue of their correlation, causing bias. Endogeneity can also arise from other sources, such as measurement error in $X$.

When working with observational data excluding the possibility of endogeneity is rarely credible. Thus, it is a substantial barrier to drawing causal conclusions (although it is not a problem for making predictions or assessing marginal relationships).

A number of techniques (other than experiments) have been developed to help address this problem. They include , , regression discontinuity designs, difference in differences (a.k.a., ), quasi-experimental designs, natural experiments, etc.

316 questions
9
votes
1 answer

Bad Controls and Omitted Variables

The traditional manner (in Economics at least) to explain an omitted variables bias involves the consideration of a Mincer type regression:$$w_{it}=\alpha+x_{it}'\beta+\gamma E_{i}+\alpha_{i}+\epsilon_{it}$$ where the LHS denotes wage of individual…
ChinG
  • 885
2
votes
1 answer

Can a bad control problem affect endogeneity?

Suppose the population regression function is as follows: $$y=\beta_{0}+\beta_{1}x_{1}+\epsilon$$ In this case, the assumptions of the linear model for obtain unbiased and consistent estimates are satisfied, namely that $E[\epsilon|…
ChinG
  • 885
2
votes
0 answers

Reduce endogeneity with lagged explanatory variables

I'm estimating a production function with panel data region level. My dependent variable is regional GDP, as explanatory variables are the stock of capital, labor and a measure of human capital. Additionally, two measures of financial development…
albert
  • 51
1
vote
1 answer

Conditional mean independence- can it be a constant

Consider the linear regression model: $$y_{i}=x_{i}'\beta+\epsilon_{i}$$ where the notation is conventional. For OLS to be unbiased, we need the conditional exogeneity assumption, or the fact that $\text{E} [\epsilon \mid x]=0$ I understand if the…
ChinG
  • 885
1
vote
2 answers

Is there a test for how appropriate a seemingly unrelated regression (SUR) is in the presence of possible endogeneity?

I have two equations which I would like to use in a SUR about innovation and investment in a specific sector: {sector innovation proxy}=a+b1{sector specific policies}+b2{general investment policies}+b3{controls}+e {sector specific…
asdir
  • 155
1
vote
1 answer

How to tackle endogenity?

I need to estimate following regresssion: $$ Price_{i} = \alpha_{i} + \beta_{i}Wage_{i} + \sum_k\gamma_{i}^{k}Z_{i}^{k} $$ where $Price_{i}$ is a price of a product, $i$ is a region number, $Z$ is a vector of exogenous variables, $k$ is an id of…
Pythia
  • 13
0
votes
0 answers

Is there a instrumental variable free approach for detecting endogeinity?

After doing some research on the topic of how to test your model for endogeinity I came across the Guassian copla approach, which is the less restrictive in this category but has some limitations as well as for example that only Second, the…
0
votes
0 answers

Endogeneity in Logistic Regression

I am currently working on a logistic regression, where innovation is my independent variable and correlation is my dependent variable. I have some other independent variables and interaction terms but this is my main effect. How do I test for…
Carla
  • 1
0
votes
1 answer

2SLS Multiple versus Single Instrumental Variable

To address endogeneity, I was wondering whether it may be easier to find many instrumental variables that predict a single instrumental variable, rather than finding a single instrumental variable. My rational is that these multiple instrumental…
0
votes
1 answer

Instrumental variable for problem of endogeneity

I have a logit model with my dependent variable being "probability of exiting unemployment" and one of my independent variables is "individual duration of unemployment". Obviously there is a huge problem of endogeneity between these two variables,…