I ran a season of 4th edition D&D Encounters, and I have the 1st 4th edition boxed set, the Red Box, and a few of the Essentials books, but I'm missing the Rules Compendium.
For some reason, I thought that rolling a natural 20 is always a "hit" in 4th edition, even if the target number is higher that 20 + your modifier. But I can't find it in the rulebooks I have.
Was I mistaken, or does a natural 20 always count as a success?
A natural 20 is always a hit, but it's only a critical hit if it would otherwise have (numerically) hit the target.
The Rules Compendium does spell this out, as it's a consolidation of the 4e core books plus errata, but it's also included in the Player's Handbook.
Player's Handbook, pages 276 and 278
Automatic Hit: If you roll a natural 20 (the die shows a 20), your attack automatically hits.
Critical Hit: If you roll a natural 20 (the die shows a 20), your attack might be a critical hit (page 278).
When you roll a natural 20 and your total attack roll is high enough to hit your target’s defense, you score a critical hit, also known as a crit.
Natural 20: If you roll a 20 on the die when making an attack roll, you score a critical hit if your total attack roll is high enough to hit your target’s defense. If your attack roll is too low to score a critical hit, you still hit automatically.
Only attack rolls have this critical exception. A natural 20 doesn't have anything special for skill checks, saving throws, or death saving throws. Death saves usually don't have modifiers though, and a 20+ lets you spend a healing surge, so natural 20 will usually get you that.
