See also: http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/24851525#24851525
– A EOct 21 '15 at 15:57
@Deusovi, your tag edits to multiple questions are changing the authors' intent. If you don't like these questions then fair enough, you can down vote them, but please don't spoil them for other people.
– A EOct 21 '15 at 20:52
@AE: At this point these puzzles have become a genre and are no longer enigmatic.
– DeusoviOct 21 '15 at 20:54
@Deusovi, you changed all of them, so "at this point" is not a relevant term. If you don't like them then fine - down vote them or ignore them - but please don't break them for other people. It's just unnecessary.
– A EOct 21 '15 at 20:57
2
@AE: Fair enough, sorry about that. What's the point of keeping the enigmatic tag when the anagram tag is there though? (And if you take off the anagram tag, then the puzzle is underclued.)
– DeusoviOct 21 '15 at 20:58
1
@Deusovi, sorry, I may have been a bit too brisk there. Apologies. Ultimately I think the point of the enigmatic tag is for where the puzzle-creator wants it to be 'underclued'. ;)
– A EOct 22 '15 at 08:03
@AE: Hm, I've always seen the enigmatic tag as one for "hunt-style" puzzles - multi-step puzzles where you'll know you're on the right track at various points throughout the puzzle. This is a prime example - no instructions are given, but the puzzle is completely solvable without any leaps of logic. Unclued anagrams are too much of a leap without any confirmation.
– DeusoviOct 22 '15 at 08:16
1
@Deusovi - Cluing an anagram makes it pointless. Most of the fun is in working out that it is an anagram. (Certainly for this series anyway.)
– AndyTOct 22 '15 at 08:23
Two different things really when we talk about 'clued' versus 'unclued': 1) Is there a clue that this is an anagram? (not explicitly, although the link to the previous question gives a strong hint) and 2) Is there a clue what the answer is meant to be? (the title). Suggest we take this discussion to meta.
– A EOct 22 '15 at 09:28
1 Answers1
6
Answer
Uncle Ogler (or of course ogler uncle)
Reason
uncle = relative
It's rather perverted if your uncle ogles you!
I was lucky to get there in time. I was in the middle of typing a long comment when you posted the question and had to react sharpish as soon as I saw it!
– chasly - supports MonicaOct 21 '15 at 09:25