I am not personally opposed but I suspect this could go under for being too broad. I am sure there is some answer where it is like WOAH BRILLIANT, but it seems initially to be broad.
– Going hamateurOct 21 '15 at 03:05
1
It was meant to be a quickie and it was. Sometimes people take these puzzles too seriously. By the way, "WOAH" was highly relevant -- your subconscious telling you the answer maybe?
– chasly - supports MonicaOct 21 '15 at 03:34
@Goinghamateur, I see what you are saying about 'too broad'. However I don't really agree. The fact that there is so little to go on surely indicates that all the required information is contained within a very small space--the title being the main part of that. Anyone who has done a cryptic crossword will recognise the "Some kind of ...?" format and thus know the types of thing to look for. An anagram is very common sort of cryptic clue. I think my judgement was borne out by the fact that you did in fact get the answer remarkably quickly.
– chasly - supports MonicaOct 21 '15 at 09:14
1
Response: http://puzzling.stackexchange.com/questions/23364/relatively-perverted
– A EOct 21 '15 at 09:18
P.S. It's noteworthy that (as I type) opinion is split. The question has 7 upvotes and 7 downvotes. I wonder if this is representative of the members as a whole? There are certainly divergent attitudes to what constitutes a 'good' question and they are generally quite polarised IMO.
– chasly - supports MonicaOct 21 '15 at 09:19