Questions tagged [group-differences]

Group differences broadly refer to statistics which quantify the differences between two or more subpopulations.

Group differences broadly refer to statistics which quantify the differences between two or more subpopulations. Examples include

  • medical trials where one group receives a drug and the others does not
  • the 90-10 earnings differential within certain education brackets
  • crime rates across social groups and districts within a city

A large array of techniques is available for assessing such differences. Common between-group tests are the Chow test, matching methods, difference-in-differences, $\chi^2$ and t-tests or Wilks' lambda. Sometimes also the within-group properties are of interest or because we may want to compare the variability within groups across groups. For instance, ANOVA can be used to separate the within- and between-variability of group data.

With observational data a common concern is that there may be unobservable factors which have led individuals to self-select into certain groups. Therefore group differences are mostly descriptive unless the data comes from a randomized experiment or methods for causal inference like matching of difference-in-differences are applied.

659 questions
4
votes
1 answer

Official name for "symmetric percent difference" function (x-y)/max(x,y)

I frequently use this formula to compare two positive numbers $x$ and $y$ to see if they are "more different" than some threshold: $$ x-y \over \max(x,y) $$ It is nice because it is symmetric and bounded to $[-1,1]$ (unlike relative percent…
J. Miller
  • 205
3
votes
1 answer

Are differences in sexual orientation statistically significant?

please be kind its been a long time since I have done any statistics! I have some sexual orientation data for three teams, which are are very different sizes from Organisation (A) to Directorate (B) and a smallish Team (C). My null hypothesis is…
3
votes
0 answers

Conclusion about between-groups differences in the absence of a baseline comparison

Many psychology studies draw conclusions from experiments that follow a design along the lines of: take two groups, and subject each of them to a different manipulation (e.g. task instructions etc) measure both groups on one and the same dependent…
z8080
  • 2,370
3
votes
1 answer

How to measure the effect of users' participation in forums?

My problem is how to measure the effect of a user's participation in forums. I calculate the user's participation as the number of discussions that user posted. My hypothesis that a users' participations are not independent of each other and that…
Gawesh
  • 31
3
votes
1 answer

test for difference between two differences (proportions)

I have 4 independent samples. Two groups A and B measured on time1 and two groups A and B measured on time2. For every group I calculate a proportion. I would like to compare the difference between the proportions over time for group A with the…
2
votes
1 answer

significant differences between groups in gender

I have a cell array containing the gender e.g. GENDER = {'Male';'Female';'Male';'Male';'Male';'Female';'Female';'Female';'Male';'Male'}; and another array containing the respective groups e.g. GROUPS = [1; 2; 1; 1; 3; 3; 1; 2; 2; 3]; I would like…
2
votes
1 answer

Comparing means between several groups

I am asking for your help. I have 3 variables that are divided into 4 groups (Quantitative variables). I intend to check if there is any difference between the groups for each variable. My difficulty in using ANOVA - it indicates that one of the…
Yael
  • 21
1
vote
0 answers

How to statistically treat my data?

Here's the situation. I have 3 set-ups: A, B, and C I want to measure 2 variables in all of them (pH and alcoholic content) over time I want to know if the pH level or alcoholic content in A is significantly higher or lower than the one in B or C…
1
vote
0 answers

How to define the cut off point?

I have population of 218 people operated on after a certain event. They are operated on from day 30 to day 911 after the event . Some of them were OK (0) and some got a complication (1). I would like to determine when is the best time to perform an…
Bojan
  • 11
1
vote
1 answer

What test to use to see if there is a difference before and after an intervention?

I have a data set constisting of gender and years (2010 representing before the improvement and 2012 representing after the improvement) and another table comparing age against the years: Before After 2010 2012 420 365 …
Anno
  • 15
  • 4
1
vote
1 answer

How can I compare cancer counts by race for 4 types of cancer

I have a set of cancer counts (incidence) for difference racial groups for 4 different types of cancer. I'd like to know if there is a difference in cancer incidence among the racial groups. So the data look a bit like this: Cancer Sites All…
Jim
  • 11
  • 1
1
vote
1 answer

How to research very unbalanced groups

I have a data set for a PhD paper in which I need to look for differences between 3 groups of observations. The issue is that ~95% are in one group and the rest are in the other two. The data table is attached below. Will any research on the…
user49422
  • 213
1
vote
0 answers

Compare grades of cohorts

I want to compare the grades of two cohorts A and B (of unequal size). I have the grades for a certain course 1. The grades are not normally distributed. I used the following code (in R) to compare: wilcox.test(gradesA, gradesB, paired=FALSE,…
dsent
  • 111
1
vote
0 answers

Is it logical to find difference between same question, same people yes/no answers but different time?

I have 22 patients with certain symptom (have(yes)/don't have(no)) before and after treatment. Is it logical to find difference between having or not having the same symptom after treatment? For example: 18 had a symptom and after treatment just 4…
Martin
  • 11
0
votes
1 answer

Comparison of means for individual vs consensus

I have a question regarding how to evaluate agreement between an individual's rating, and that of a group of people (of which the individual was a part). The group score was achieved through consensus (i.e. they agreed on one score as a group). I…
JonasE
  • 1
1
2