7

I was so convinced that the "correct" answers to this excellent question were wrong that I took out a deck of cards to prove it. Then I realised that I was changing one of the rules. So here's the alternate version with Bob's rules:

Alice and Bob are going to have a poker night. They have invented a variant where there are no secrets, and no randomness, called Face-Up Poker. Today, however, the table is full of work and so they're playing on the floor Here's how it works.

A standard 52 card deck is spread face up on the floor.

  • Alice picks up any 5 cards from the floor. Bob does the same.
  • Alice discards any number of cards, throwing them on the floor. She then picks up the same number of cards from the floor.
  • Bob does the same. (He can pick up cards Alice discarded. This is the difference from the other question.)
  • They then compare hands, and the best hand wins, with Bob winning ties.

Which player can force a win? What is their winning strategy?

This puzzle assumes familiarity with the rankings of poker hands, but no other knowledge of the rules of poker. For a refresher these rankings, see this helpful page (the hands are listed worst to best from top to bottom).

Community
  • 1
Akshay Rangnekar
  • 73
  • 3
  • Clarification needed: The cards Alice throws on the floor, are they counted as "face-up" being available to Bob or are they "lost" to the game? – BmyGuest Jun 05 '15 at 10:58
  • To b eclear, the only difference with the other game is that Bob can take the cards that Alice discarded, correct? – oerkelens Jun 05 '15 at 12:34
  • @oerkelens - that's right the only difference is that Bob can take the cards that Alice discarded. This however changes the entire game. – Akshay Rangnekar Jun 05 '15 at 14:19

2 Answers2

10

I don't think Alice can win this version.

All 52 cards are available to Bob, apart from the 5 in Alice's hand.

If she starts with a royal flush, so too will Bob, making it a tie, meaning Bob wins

If she acts in any way to block a royal flush, then it doesn't matter what Bob takes. Since she discards first, Bob always has the option to equal or better her hand.

She either has 4 of a kind and Bob has a straight flush, or they both have a royal flush. Either way, Bob wins

To summarise enormously:

There are is no five card poker hand you can remove from a deck of 52 cards that can't at least be equalled by another hand chosen from the remainder

LowIntHighCha
  • 8,596
  • 26
  • 50
  • 1
    Right. Actually, with the lack of discarded cards, it doesn't matter what either of them choose in the first round. In the second round, the highest unique (non-replicable) hand that Alice can choose is 4 Aces, which Bob can beat with a straight flush. – Akshay Rangnekar Jun 05 '15 at 14:21
0

Bob, by selecting a royal flush, and no discarding of cards? He has the highest combination possible, and he wins when Alice has the same combination.

Mathias711
  • 1,787
  • 1
  • 14
  • 28