35

Yesterday, House Republicans voted to remove Liz Cheney of Wyoming from the #3 position in their leadership:

In a remarkable display of loyalty to Donald J. Trump, Republicans moved quickly to purge Representative Liz Cheney of Wyoming from House leadership on Wednesday, voting to oust their No. 3 for repudiating the former president’s election lies and holding him responsible for the deadly Jan. 6 riot at the Capitol. (Source: New York Times)

While I know it has to do in part with her vote to Impeach former President Trump, and her opposition to his claims about election fraud, it seems like there must be something else there. Cheney successfully fought off a similar leadership challenge just a few months ago, and the kinds of criticism she directed at Trump were quite common among Republicans (including many of the ones who voted against her) back in January. So what's changed? Why is she being purged now?

henning
  • 545
  • 5
  • 18
divibisan
  • 25,926
  • 6
  • 110
  • 135

4 Answers4

50

I rather liked Byron York's piece, in the Washington examiner, on it

Cheney's current problems intensified after the first vote on her leadership, when she intensified her campaign against Trump. Cheney's efforts were undoubtedly media-friendly — she was portrayed as a profile in courage by some media outlets — but many Republicans came to believe, with some reason, that she had become a distraction from the GOP's mission to oppose the Biden agenda and win back the House in 2022. Instead, Cheney seemed determined to re-fight the battles of November 2020 to January 2021.

And later

For her part, Cheney is now making clear that she has become something of a single-issue politician and that her single issue is Trump. Recently, the Washington Post, citing interviews with a dozen people, reported that Cheney's "determination to name, shame and banish Trump ... had become fundamental to her political purpose." Now, CNN reports that Cheney is "planning to wage a protracted political war — through public statements and in the media — against the former president." And it will not just be a war against Trump. Axios recently reported that part of Cheney's strategy involves "baiting" fellow Republicans over their support of the ex-president.

The simple fact is that Cheney took her momentum from the prior battle to stay as leader and started an open campaign against Trump. Last week, Cheney wrote a rather scathing op-ed about the party as a whole. I found another article that has a small excerpt

"Trump is seeking to unravel critical elements of our constitutional structure that make democracy work - confidence in the result of elections and the rule of law. No other American president has ever done this," Cheney said in the column.

It's hard to get a sense of where the GOP is. This quote from York's piece epitomizes a lot of GOP sentiment I've seen

"I don't think the party has surrendered to Trump," the second lawmaker said, addressing a common media talking point. "But we are beholden to those who supported most of the policies that we voted for and agreed with. I'm not beholden to Donald Trump, but a lot of his policies were awfully good for the country, and a lot of people support that."

The GOP is caught between a rock and a hard place at present. On the one hand, Trump was quite popular with the GOP base (Trump had an 82% approval among GOP voters on Jan 4). On the other, there was the capitol riot, which came on the heels of the "stolen election" narrative (wherein Trump went to war with his own party, going so far as to vow to campaign against GOP incumbents in Georgia). The bulk of the problem with Cheney seems to be that she kept stirring the Trump pot (even as Trump is gradually losing support).

henning
  • 545
  • 5
  • 18
Machavity
  • 48,310
  • 11
  • 131
  • 209
  • 1
    To mention Trump's approval rating of what it was 2 days *before* rioters attacked the USA capitol and brutally killed a Capitol Police officer protecting the American capitol seems a bit disingenuous. Since this question asks about Cheney today, and not on or before Jan 4th, it would be more more relevant to present approval numbers AFTER the riots took place (for which he was, once again, impeached). – End Anti-Semitic Hate May 16 '21 at 05:11
  • 5
    @RockPaperLz-MaskitorCasket A couple of things there. 1. I mention the pre-riot numbers (which were quite high) and contrast them with his numbers now (which are not). Those high numbers still weigh heavily on the GOP, even though they have fallen 2. The capitol police officer died of natural causes. Initial reporting was incorrect. No officers were killed by rioters, although many were injured. – Machavity May 16 '21 at 11:59
  • 1
  • Where do you contrast the numbers? You provided only a single percentage. 2. Thank you for the article you linked, as I had obviously never seen it. Quoting from it: "Diaz’s ruling does not mean Sicknick was not assaulted or that the violent events at the Capitol did not contribute to his death. The medical examiner noted Sicknick was among the officers who engaged the mob and said “all that transpired played a role in his condition.”"
  • – End Anti-Semitic Hate May 16 '21 at 22:21
  • I noted at the end that Trump's current numbers are nowhere near as high 2. The point there is he didn't die in the widely reported method of "being struck with a fire extinguisher" (which was listed in the Impeachment). It doesn't exonerate Trump, but neither does it condemn him.
  • – Machavity May 17 '21 at 02:37