16

The toddler is 2 years 3 months old.

The blue part in following sketch has been solely coloured by her. Red part has been coloured by me.

enter image description here

At what age should I tell her to be mindful of the boundaries while colouring?

Aquarius_Girl
  • 6,334
  • 26
  • 72
  • 139
  • 18
    In my opinion: never.... – Stephie Oct 11 '15 at 12:14
  • Why do you want them to draw inside the boundaries? Is it to test/train their fine motor skills, or just because you feel the color should be within the lines? – Erik Oct 11 '15 at 18:31
  • 19
    I'll try to develop an answer, but in the meantime I want to say, "Wow!" those blue parts are very close to being in the lines, which is a great accomplishment for a recently-two-year-old. She is clearly coloring the objects, rather than the page itself. –  Oct 11 '15 at 21:56
  • @Erik colour should be within the lines, that is the reason. I didn't know it has anything to do with fine motor skills. – Aquarius_Girl Oct 12 '15 at 00:10
  • 4
    When it comes to art and creativity, "should" is a limiting factor. I can understand the desire to make sure kids have the motor skills to do the task, but telling them they "should" draw within the lines will ultimately just hurt their creativity. – Erik Oct 12 '15 at 06:20
  • 2
    Looking closely at the picture: Did you notice that not even you managed to colour within the lines? Your paper seems to encourage the "bleeding" of the pen and the tip seems to be too wide for such detailed work. Let me suggest that once your child approaches or has reached the fine motor skills to accomplish the task, you also supply her with the appropriate tools to do so. – Stephie Oct 12 '15 at 07:06
  • 1
    And just an additional note on why some here might disagree with the premise of the question (no, I didn't downvote), especially for a child of this young age: http://elf2.library.ca.gov/training/docs/WhatsWrongwithColoringBooks.pdf – Stephie Oct 12 '15 at 07:16
  • 2
    @Stephie Did you notice that not even you managed to colour within the lines? Wow, Yesterday I did think that somewhat would point out that bit. I should have mentioned this in the post itself that I have "delibrately" been careless because I was colouring with the "child". – Aquarius_Girl Oct 12 '15 at 07:23
  • @Stephie I'd be interested to see a full answer from you along that line, if only for a complementary viewpoint. – Dan Henderson Oct 12 '15 at 12:26
  • @DanHenderson Unlikely. Mainly because we have the policy of not arguing with the premise of a question. The physiological /developmental aspects of the question are covered already and differentiating between the merits of coloring (= fine motor skills) vs. free drawing (= fostering creativity and confidence and leading to writing skills) are clearly outside the scope of the question. That's why I choose to mention them in comments instead of writing an answer that doesn't adress the question. Shoud OP edit / expand the question, I'd be happy to oblige. – Stephie Oct 12 '15 at 12:31
  • @Stephie I request you to edit the question and add the unasked question and then answer it. Please, that will help us all. – Aquarius_Girl Oct 12 '15 at 12:47
  • @TheIndependentAquarius Can do, but not before tonight or tomorrow. – Stephie Oct 12 '15 at 12:56
  • 2
    My daughter is 2 years 8 months old and doesn't do any better, I would even say slightly worse. From what I experience with her and other children that age, I would say your kid seems actually more advanced on this than other kids... – Laurent S. Oct 12 '15 at 14:15
  • @LaurentS. Happy to know that. Touch wood. This child has an astonishing attention span when it comes to story reading - from me. – Aquarius_Girl Oct 12 '15 at 14:59
  • 1
    I've asked the other question that seemed to be lurking... http://parenting.stackexchange.com/questions/22512/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-colouring-books – A E Oct 12 '15 at 18:02
  • Never tell them to stay within the lines. They will figure that out in good time. – Ruralife Oct 18 '15 at 04:38
  • Personal anecdote here: My primary school teachers put me down as mentally subnormal at school. One reason (among several) was that on my first day in Reception class we were told to colour in a picture, and I didn't have the first idea. Crayons were banned at home because my grandmother was worried that we would scribble on the walls. – Paul Johnson Oct 29 '16 at 10:25

2 Answers2

21

The question of when to address coloring inside the lines is actually a question of child development, especially fine motor skills.

While there could be philosophical arguments about whether it's good or bad for a child's creativity to have them work inside the constraints of lines, I believe that clouds the specific issue (and is a different question). Instead, we need to focus on whether or not it's a task the child is actually capable of.

When can children stay inside the lines while coloring?

Much of the information out there points to the same age range, but this article, Fine Motor Development 0-6 Years (PDF), summarizes it quite nicely:

3 to 4 Years
Your child will have a strong preference for a lead/dominant hand, but switching continues. When drawing, the lead hand will be holding the crayon while the assist hand is stabilizing the paper. Your child will progress from being able to copy lines & circles to imitating crosses (+) & tracing over triangles & diamonds. The child will attempt to colour within the lines but with limited success. By 4 years of age, your child should be holding the crayon with three fingers

And:

4 to 5 Years
During this stage hand use is characterized by refined wrist & finger movement & decreased elbow & shoulder movement. During drawing, a combination of finger & wrist movement should be observed. Hand dominance is typically established between 4 & 6 years, so a hand preference should be apparent & consistent. As a result, the skill of the dominant hand should begin to exceed the skill of the nondominant hand. During colouring, the child will become capable of staying within the lines as well as copying crosses, diagonal lines & squares using a tripod pencil grasp.

What we see here is that around the age of 3, children start being developmentally capable of trying to stay in the lines. This has to do with a combination of cognitive ability, grip, and fine motor control.

Then, sometime during their fourth year, children become more adept at staying within the lines.

It's important to note that these are generalized developmental milestones, and not hard and fast timelines.

This study, Descriptive Analysis of the Developmental Progression of Grip Position for Pencil and Crayon Control in Nondysfunctional Children, found some trends in the way children hold their writing/drawing implements based on their age. They identified two "mature grips" that are essentially the traditional pencil grips we're taught to use. While age breakdowns available in the article are interesting, this excerpt really highlights the concept of development:

Coloring
During the administration of the coloring task, we noted that often the children would first color the edge of the circle using a more mature grip and then color in the center of the circle using a less mature grip. This was more noticeable in younger children; older children would simply slow down to color the edge and then continue with the same grip for the center of the circle. We chose to analyze the grip used to color the center of the circle.

What this clearly shows is that children typically need to have the fine motor control and grip strength necessary for a traditional, "mature" grip in order to stay within the lines. They may start using that method just for the edges, while going back to the physically-easier methods of coloring the insides of the drawing until their grip strength and stamina improves.

How does this answer the question?

It lets us know that, at a minimum, this shouldn't be a concern for parents until around the ages of three or four. Unless there's a clear developmental problem, there probably doesn't need to be any extra coaching on the matter. Children will develop the grip necessary to complete the task most efficiently as they get older.

The most effective way for them to improve their strength and control is by giving them plenty of opportunity to practice. Rather than focusing on whether or not they're able to stay in the lines, you should focus on whether or not they're getting enough opportunities to develop.

When should you actually tell children to stay within the lines?

There may be a time when it's appropriate to advise your child to specifically be mindful of the lines. This would be a time after you know they've already developed enough to be capable of minding the boundaries, but for reason they aren't doing so.

A clear example is one from my own youth: I would often rush to complete a drawing or coloring page, and in my excited impatience fail to take the time necessary to stay in the lines. Here, my specific problem was more behavioral, and a reminder to take my time and to be calm would help to address the problem.

I expect this to happen sometime around age six. Six years old is frequently seen as a delimiter between stages of artistic/fine motor development in children. This chart, Drawing Development in Children, shows that two other drawing development experts believe a new stage of drawing development starts around age six.

Community
  • 1
0

Never! colouring is good for fine motor skills but the theory now is that it kills their creativity and there are plenty of other ways to practice fine motor skills without stubbing out creativity. This is why most ECE centres that are using current theories and teaching pedagogies dont do colouring in at all.

user38719
  • 11
  • Hi! Welcome to the site. Can you add some references to back your statement? As it stands the original question asks for an age; I think "never" is a valid answer to that (i.e., "at no age"), but it is a strong statement and as such requires equally strong proof. Thanks! – Joe Apr 28 '20 at 16:24