10

Two native speakers were chatting about what kinds of 風邪 can be cured by 抗生物質 (antibiotics). I linked to an English-language study showing that common cold can not be cured by 抗生物質. To which their answer was that 風邪 is different from common cold:

日本語の風邪という言葉はだいぶ意味がひろいような気がする。
風邪は病気の名前じゃなくて症状の総称みたいな感じだね。高熱、咳、鼻水、みたいな症状は全部風邪って言われる。

So, does 風邪 differ in scope from the disease known as common cold, and if yes, how?

Nicolas Raoul
  • 8,650
  • 3
  • 30
  • 78
  • Most Jp ppl don't make a dictinction between Cold and Flu. – HizHa Sep 05 '16 at 19:54
  • 1
    @H.Ha 「風邪とインフルエンザを区別しない」という意味なんだったら、そんなことは流石にないと思いますが。 – naruto Sep 06 '16 at 14:11

1 Answers1

3

Experts tend not to use the word 風邪 in serious documents in the first place, because there is no strict definition which they can rely on. Even Wikipedia says "医学的な(風邪の)定義は文献によって異なっている". In clinical practice, a wide variety of diseases cause cold-like symptoms, so physicians tend to use a bit vaguer but safer terms such as かぜ症候群 (症候群 = syndrome), 急性上気道炎 or 普通感冒.

According to The Japanese Respiratory Society, most (but not all) かぜ症候群 cases are viral, of course, and thus antibiotics are not effective. But they say some of them are actually bacterial, although antibiotics are still generally unnecessary anyway (unless complicated with secondary infections and/or other diseases). Many Japanese articles (like this one) acknowledge the existence of 細菌性の風邪 ("bacterial 風邪"). On the other hand, many English sources (incl. Wikipedia, Mayo Clinic and WebMD) seem to say "common cold" is strictly viral, so Japanese 風邪 or かぜ症候群 may have a broader sense than "common cold".

That said, antibiotics are not necessary regardless of the type of microorganisms, so I agree with your attitude towards 風邪 :-) You can find tons of Japanese articles saying how improperly some Japanese people demand the prescription of antibiotics once they feel slightly sick.

naruto
  • 313,860
  • 13
  • 324
  • 625
  • "some Japanese people demand ...". For me it's usually the other way around. Doctors want to give me a mountain of medicine (including antibiotics) to earn their points, I guess, and I have to convince them I don't need it. – dainichi Sep 06 '16 at 23:32
  • @dainichi Japan has "flat prescription fee" system, so the number of medicines and the remunation points are irrelevant in most cases. (See: http://goo.gl/IvZ60g) – naruto Sep 07 '16 at 01:27