The question is basically about the use of the verb "suggest" and the grammatical structure that accompanies it. I know that I can say "I suggest that you read that book" or
"I suggest reading that book", but I want to know if the expression "I suggest your reading that book" is correct.
Asked
Active
Viewed 311 times
0
-
What do you want 'I suggest your reading that book' to mean? – Void May 27 '21 at 19:49
-
I don't think you can, but I don't know how to explain the grammar of it exactly. The construction you're trying to use (verb + possessive + gerund) doesn't work with "suggest" which needs an action. "Your reading that book" is more like a noun. "Your reading that banned book caused me to lose my job. I strongly suggest (that) you not read any more banned books." – ColleenV May 27 '21 at 20:10
-
This may help Is 'his not having a name' grammatical correct? – ColleenV May 27 '21 at 20:20
1 Answers
1
It is an expression that is probably correct. I say "probably" because there is almost no situation in which you would actually use "I suggest your reading...". It is always better to say "I suggest that you read..."
But a gerund/participle "reading" can have a subject in possessive form "your reading" (normally the subject is implied and omitted). I understand that meaning of the expression, but I would never use it. So it marginally correct...but don't use it (unless you need it for poetic reasons etc.)
James K
- 217,650
- 16
- 258
- 452