22

Uranus is called a green planet, although it appears blue in many of the photographs including those taken by spacecraft, like Voyager 2, Hubble, and JWST. NASA's Uranus page mentions it to be bluish-green.

One of the reasons mentioned is due to the presence of methane in the atmosphere of Uranus. But if that's the case, why can't we see this green color in the photos? I am unable to exactly grasp the mechanism behind the green color.

Peter Mortensen
  • 301
  • 2
  • 8
Dhruv Nayak
  • 677
  • 2
  • 8

5 Answers5

43

I think your issue is linguistic not astronomical. The way a language cuts up the space of colours into discrete names is varies strongly from one language to another, and even from one dialect to another. Translating colour names is fraught with difficulty.

Uranus has a colour that is approximated by an RGB value with approximately equal amounts of green and blue (I've found the value #B2D6DB, but monitors vary, so this isn't absolute). You might describe this as "light green-blue" or "light blue-green" or "pale teal" or "pale aqua" or "duck-egg", or some form of "turquoise".

However, the usual contrast in terms of colour is with Neptune, which much closer to an azure or cerulean blue. Uranus may not be "green", but it is "greener than Neptune".

The images below show the RGB value and a colour photo of Uranus by an Earth based observer which shows a turquoise colour

enter image description hereenter image description here

James K
  • 120,702
  • 5
  • 298
  • 423
  • 1
    (+1) Nice answer!, I also faced the same problem while comparing the wavelength to the color, I couldn't find a color for the peak wavelength – Arjun Sep 17 '23 at 06:50
  • Thats nice. Got much clarity regarding this issue. Thank you :) – Dhruv Nayak Sep 17 '23 at 07:22
  • 1
    Actually, I have to explain this to 6th graders and I wasn't exactly able to understand how to explain this to them, since, I myself was a bit perplexed by reading the info. available on the internet. – Dhruv Nayak Sep 17 '23 at 07:25
  • Related article to differentiating between green/blue: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-019-0341-7 and https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/ssqu.13074 – samcarter_is_at_topanswers.xyz Sep 17 '23 at 09:31
  • @samcarter your second link is irrelevant as it is about perceoptions of "Green spaces" ie opinions about parks and gardens; not about colour. – James K Sep 17 '23 at 09:53
  • 8
    The image is cropped from four - each of them shows the same basic color, even the infrared ones. This one is called "straight RGB" but no information is given about color correction, white balance, etc. There's no reason to believe this one has any bearing on the "true color" of the light, which is a murky concept at best to begin with (cf. Billmeyer and Saltzman's Principles of Color Technology 3rd/4th edition) The image's color has been process SEVERAL times, for "internet color" possibly for your device's screen's pallet. – uhoh Sep 17 '23 at 09:55
  • 3
    to even begin to get "the color of Neptune" it will take either a proper RGB recording through a good quality Bayer filter followed by fastidious color correction for the camera's own bias, or better yet, staring from a recorded, calibrated photometric spectrum, then apply the proper projection on to RGB space. Good luck! See for example this answer to Need help simulating solar limb darkening – uhoh Sep 17 '23 at 10:00
  • 7
    "Translating colour names is fraught with difficulty." - So is specifying colours objectively. Monitor RGB values simply won't do it, for a large number of reasons. Better to speak in terms of the spectrum that is actually reflected from the planet's surface (intensity at each wavelength), either with or without the filtering of Earth's atmosphere. – Karl Knechtel Sep 17 '23 at 18:43
  • 3
    @KarlKnechtel I agree completely. ..."colours are hard"... But working with spectra is well beyond what is needed to explain this to a bunch of sixth grade kids. All you need is "It looks greeny-blue. More green than Neptune (because of the methane)" In this sense #B2D6DB is a "lie to children". – James K Sep 17 '23 at 19:34
  • 3
    Specifying or reproducing colors is immensely complicated, but you don't really need an objective definition of what exact shades qualify as "green" here. If you show someone pictures of Neptune and Uranus taken with similar processing, as long as it's reasonably accurate, and say "the green one", it'll be immediately obvious which one is meant. It's not really an attempt to describe the precise color. – Christopher James Huff Sep 17 '23 at 22:23
  • Color names being cultural is indeed an interesting problem (btw for me the included picture seems a lot closer to green than to blue). There is an interesting myth about people in ancient times not being able to perceive the color blue, because in the oldest ancient Greek texts don't mention the color blue, and many things we consider to be blue (the sky, or the ocean) are described by other means. However, it is most likely cultural, as for example what we call "white wine" does not look like milk, so why call it white? And the skin color of what we call white people is also not like milk. – vsz Sep 18 '23 at 04:47
  • @JamesK Oh, sorry! I must have mixed up the links when copying them into the comments. Sorry for the confusion! – samcarter_is_at_topanswers.xyz Sep 18 '23 at 13:38
  • @JamesK why are the other infrared images that you cropped away from this one also the same color? https://i.stack.imgur.com/Fon8j.jpg Don't you think it's much more likely that the author chose a color they liked and made all four the some color using artistic license? In which case isn't this answer of zero scientific value and quite misleading? Of course to some that doesn't matter as long as those reputation points keep rolling in but YOU SHOULD HAVE SHOWN THE OTHER THREE IMAGES rather than crop them out so folks have a better idea what this one is or isn't in terms of color representation – uhoh Sep 18 '23 at 21:19
  • 1
    I don't know why you're getting angry. Its an IR filter, to bring out clouds, and not a infrared image (in the way that JWST are infrared. I cropped so it would fit on a screen better, the original is linked. As of "of zero scientific value", you are just ranting at this point. and the shouting doesn't help. – James K Sep 18 '23 at 21:29
  • Assuming the RGB given is the whole story (despite some comments to the contrary), it's also almost as red, so one could make a case for calling it grey. – J.G. Sep 19 '23 at 06:19
  • the primary colors of paint (reflect light) are red yellow and blue; the primary colors of light (emitting) are red green and blue; the other colors are composed from these; so equal amounts of red and green, with less or zero blue, is yellow; equal amounts of green and blue, with less or zero red, is cyan or turquoise, the color of Uranus; equal amounts of red and blue, with less or zero green, is magenta (pink) – jmarina Sep 19 '23 at 08:06
  • A point that might be relevant to the discussion: many cultures don't really have much of a clear separation between green and blue, which are often considered varying shades of some underlying unified color. Even in Japanese and Chinese, two quite significant cultures, has this been true historically (Japanese "ao"/"aoi" and Chinese "qīng", both meaning either "blue" or "green" depending on context). – Outis Nemo Sep 19 '23 at 10:24
17

This answer looks into why Uranus is "green" or at least greener compared with Neptune's blue.

Both planets have similar atmospheric compositions and would ordinarily be expected to show similar colors. But according to a study by the National Science Foundation's NOIRLab program, the greater atmospheric activity of Neptune's atmosphere tends to break up the smog of more complex hydrocarbons which, on Uranus, tends to make the externally observed color of Uranus whiter and greener than the methane would otherwise be expected to give. The technical reference is from [Irwin et al.1](https://doi.org/10.1029/2022JE007189), and is open access. The figure below, taken from this reference, shows the brighter transmission in Neptune at blue and violet wavelengths compared with Uranus, whereas Uranus becomes slightly brighter at longer wavelengths and less blue/violet selective overall.

enter image description here

We actually see a similar effect on Earth. In this question the whitening of the sky near the horizon is discussed in terms of increased Rayleigh scattering, which would be caused by the smoggy conditions on Uranus too. One answer demonstrates through photography that the sky hue on Earth also tends to become greener as it becomes whiter, matching well with the difference between Uranus and Neptune.

Reference (open access)

  1. Irwin, P. G. J., Teanby, N. A., Fletcher, L. N., Toledo, D., Orton, G. S., Wong, M. H., et al. (2022). "Hazy blue worlds: A holistic aerosol model for Uranus and Neptune, including dark spots". Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets, 127, e2022JE007189. https://doi.org/10.1029/2022JE007189
jmarina
  • 249
  • 1
  • 2
  • 6
Oscar Lanzi
  • 1,113
  • 3
  • 15
8

This is just a mere illusion. In reality, the peak wavelength is actually between green and blue, that is slightly cyanish/turquoise. The reason this happens is because the atmosphere of Uranus contains methane, which has an absorption wavelength between yellow to red leading to blue/green reflected wavelength. In the albedo of 30% of the sunlight reflected by Uranus, blue green light is absorbed the most.

This wavelength is however scattered in our atmosphere, via atmosphere refraction, specifically Rayleigh scattering which leads to telluric absorption which leads to a few wavelengths being scattered more like blue wavelengths, which is precisely observed in the ground-based telescope images. In space-based telescopes where there is nill telluric scattering, the actual color is perceived.

Even though the green color is more sensitive to our light cones, green light is already absorbed by our atmosphere, before reaching our eye.

This is quite similar to how the Sun's peak wavelength is green, but we perceive it as yellow, except the atmospheric refraction is different in this case.

Space telescope:

Enter image description here

vs.

Ground-based telescope:

Enter image description here

It's not leaned towards pure green or pure blue. The Rayleigh scattering absorbs only few nms, like around 30-40 nm.

In conclusion:

This is a mere mirage by the atmospheric scattering of the Earth, aerosols like to absorb more green than blue due to their electrons and quantum mechanics even though Uranus is lying between green and blue.

Peter Mortensen
  • 301
  • 2
  • 8
Arjun
  • 1,256
  • 2
  • 21
6

A convenient pattern

Uranus’ color is somewhere between green and blue. Since a lot of space trivia is in the purview of elementary education, and since patterns are useful for memorizing, it’s convenient to fudge color names to fit the pattern:

  • Mars is red.
  • Jupiter is orange*.
  • Saturn is yellow.
  • Uranus is green.
  • Neptune is blue.

*If you squint, red + yellow = orange, and brown is a dark shade of orange. Again, fudging. “thick red, brown, yellow and white clouds“. “shades of white, orange, brown and red”. “shades of white, orange, brown, and red”.

Spencer Joplin
  • 281
  • 1
  • 6
5

Although both Uranus and Neptune exhibit a color palette ranging from deep blue to pale green, there is a prime difference in the atmospheric composition which determines the color difference.

In the outer layers of the atmosphere, Uranus has other hydrocarbons which are heavier than methane, mainly ethane and acetylene. These substances form tiny crystals that hang in the atmosphere which causes formation of fog and it lets through waves of different wavelengths with different efficiency and it is the deep blue color that is absorbed more efficiently and leaving behind a pale-green color which we perceive. Moreover, the atmosphere of Uranus is calmer than Neptune. So, this fog is not being torn into separate bands of clouds and hence it covers the entire planet more or less evenly.

On the other hand, Neptune also has such a layer of fog but it is much thinner and cannot obscure the blue color properly as there is not enough fog to absorb it.

enter image description here

Source: https://universemagazine.com/en/green-planet-for-the-green-holiday/

Nilay Ghosh
  • 4,452
  • 1
  • 16
  • 45
  • Follow up question: https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/questions/54821/why-are-heavier-hydrocarbons-not-present-in-lower-part-of-uranian-atmosphere – Nilay Ghosh Sep 24 '23 at 07:32