Unless someone comes up with some heavy magic, I'm going to say: "No". Apple lists the apps that can open that file type in alphabetical order. (Higher versions of the same app are listed first.)
The practical ways around this are removing apps or changing them when they offer to open a type you don’t want or establishing drop folders that open dropped documents in the app of your choosing when sending a document to the non-preferred app.
For example, LaunchBar app has a send to feature that lets you send a file to any app quickly with a couple key strokes, which does take setup and training.